Why so many games use a d-pad and two buttons
Pick up a Game Boy, a NES controller or a phone game with on-screen buttons, and your thumbs know what to do within seconds: one thumb steers, the other presses A or B. That layout has outlived dozens of fancier controllers.
Where the d-pad came from
Before the d-pad, most home games used joysticks or paddles. Joysticks were big and fragile, which made them a poor fit for something carried in a pocket. Nintendo's multi-screen Donkey Kong Game & Watch, released in 1982, used a flat, cross-shaped pad instead: press one arm of the cross and the character moves that way. The design is widely credited to Gunpei Yokoi's team at Nintendo.
The same cross went onto the Famicom and NES controllers with 2 action buttons, A and B, plus Select and Start. The Game Boy kept the same set in 1989. Almost every console controller since has included a d-pad, even after analog sticks arrived. Our handheld history traces that line from 1980 to phones.
Why two buttons are enough
Two buttons cover a surprising range of games. In a platformer, A jumps and B runs or attacks. In a shooter, A fires and B drops a bomb. In a puzzle game, A rotates one way and B the other. In a sports game, A passes and B shoots.
The limit helps the player and the designer:
- Nothing to memorise. A new player can try both buttons in the first 5 seconds and know the whole control scheme.
- Every action has a cost. With only 2 buttons, a designer has to choose what matters most. That choice usually becomes the heart of the game.
- Depth comes from timing. Holding a button versus tapping it, pressing it in mid-air, or combining it with a direction gives a lot of moves without adding hardware.
- It works on anything. Arrow keys and 2 letter keys exist on every keyboard. A touch screen has room for a stick and 2 buttons. Any game controller has a d-pad and at least 2 face buttons.
Designing for minimal controls
If you're planning a small game, it helps to start from the controls and work outward.
- Name the main verb. What does the player do most? Jump, shoot, dig, steer, catch. That's button A.
- Pick a second verb, or skip it. B should be a different kind of action, like a dash, a shield or a special move. Plenty of good games use only A.
- Let the d-pad carry movement. Up and down can also aim, climb or choose a lane.
- Avoid hidden combos. If a move needs 3 buttons at once, most players will never find it.
Our design tips for small games page goes further, and how to write a game idea shows how to describe controls in a sentence.
How holos map the d-pad and buttons
Every holo runs on the X1, a console with one small pixel screen, a d-pad and two buttons, A and B. The same game works on every device you play it on.
| Device | Move | A and B | Other keys |
|---|---|---|---|
| Computer | Arrow keys | Space, X, Enter | Esc pauses, R restarts, F full screen, M mutes |
| Phone or tablet | On-screen thumb stick | On-screen A and B buttons, labelled with what they do, such as "Jump"; tapping the screen presses A | |
| Game controller | Gamepads work too, so you can play with a controller connected to your computer | ||
On a phone, the buttons show what each one does in that particular game, so you're never guessing whether A jumps or shoots. Each holo's page also lists its controls next to the original idea.
Ideas that fit two buttons
The best holo ideas usually have one clear action. Here are a few that fit the layout well:
- A frog who delivers mail across a busy river of logs and turtles, jumping with ABuild this
- A tiny wizard who zaps ants with A and drops a sugar decoy with B to protect a birthday cakeBuild this
- A mole who digs with A and builds a wall with B to steer an underground flood away from its burrowBuild this
- A goalkeeper crab who dives left and right with the d-pad and punches the ball away with ABuild this
- A snowplough driver who steers down a mountain road and honks with B to scare deer off the laneBuild this
Press "Build this" on any of them, or write your own in the make form. You can also browse every holo to see how other people used A and B.
HOLO X1 isn't affiliated with Nintendo or any other company named on this page.